The Class Divide In White America

Originally Posted At
By Steven Malanga
February 1, 2012

By now Americans have heard just about every idea on how to fix our dismal economy, and we're only half way through the presidential election campaign. Much of the talk has centered on seemingly technical issues: the best tax policy to create jobs, the right design for programs to retrain those out of work, the best ways to measure and improve our schools in their jobs of educating the next generation of worker.

A worker's economic fortunes, however, aren't solely a function of his training and intelligence, or of the opportunities around him. They are also the product of personal qualities, like industriousness, self-discipline, thrift and reliability. And these don't simply arise spontaneously in us; they are cultivated by our parents, our neighbors, our schools. Preserving those qualities when they start to fade in a society isn't as easy as retooling the factory across town or starting up a store-front worker retraining program in a depressed neighborhood. Perhaps that's why politicians run from discussing the subject of the virtues essential for individual success in America. Better to cut ribbons on new schools, kiss babies and blame global forces for our economic woes.

In The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism, Daniel Bell described the great movement in America, beginning in the 1960s, to reject those traditional qualities around which modern society had been organized and democracy and capitalism flourished. Out went a reverence for the strive and succeed work ethic, and what arose instead was what Bell described as a cultural revolution embracing an "aesthetic justification for life" in which "nothing is forbidden, all is to be explored." What grew was a disdain for institutions like marriage, religion, and the traditional workplace. By the 1970s Tom Wolfe could describe an emerging ‘me' generation whose pursuit of self-fulfillment one could see reflected in everything from declining worker productivity to rising numbers of divorces and children born to unmarried parents.

Much of this revolution originated among America's prosperous citizens and their children. And it only took some 20 years for them to see and understand the impact of this new ethic on themselves and their children and to begin rejecting it. Marriage rates stabilized among the prosperous, divorce declined, the pursuit of advanced degrees in a world that increasingly rewarded education grew.

But the rest of society didn't find it so easy to simply put on the breaks of this great cultural revolution and re-adopt the essential virtues for success. In The Dream and the Nightmare: The Sixties Legacy to the Underclass, Myron Magnet wrote of how America's elites were in a far better position to recover from their dalliance with a life in pursuit of self-gratification. Divorce might have been painful for their children, but the well-educated also had the resources to continue living comfortably in separate households after their marriages split up. When their kids who had dropped out of school in the 1960s suddenly decided it was time to go back, they could rely on parents with the wherewithal to send them on to a college education, and the cost was perhaps only a few years squandered.

The toll was far higher on those at the bottom of the economic rung, however. They found it more difficult to recover from family break up, from experiments with drugs, from dropping out of school. What arose from their failure to pick themselves up was an increase in intergenerational poverty as single, uneducated parents without skills, training or a grounding in the strive and succeed ethic themselves failed to pass on to their children the right script for success in America.

Now along comes Charles Murray who, in his new book Coming Apart: The State of White America, 1960-2010, argues convincingly that the nightmare has spread far beyond the lowest economic rungs of America. There are two America's, Murray argues, and they diverge principally in their adherence to what he calls the Founding virtues. Whatever they may preach or however they may vote, members of our prosperous classes continue to embrace those virtues and transmit them to their children, while a growing portion of our working classes increasingly do not live by them. If you have not been following the data you might be surprised, even shocked, by what Murray tells us.

In a fictional town Murray creates called Belmont, the archetypal white upper middle class neighborhood, adherence to the qualities that Murray says helped create two centuries of American exceptionalism are not very different today than before the cultural revolution. Today, 83 percent of all adults are married and their children are growing up in intact households. Fewer than six percent of all births in Belmont are to unmarried parents. In Belmont, only 12 percent of workers work fewer than 40 hours a week on average. The rate of imprisonment for residents of Belmont averages just 27 per every 100,000 residents.

The numbers are quite different in a fictional white working class neighborhood, which Murray calls Fishtown. There, the percentages of adults who are married has slid from 84 in the 1960s to 48 today. Nonmarital births to women in Fishtown have increased from a mere 6 percent some 50 years ago to 44 percent today (and are increasing at such a rate that they may soon account for half of all white working class births). That increase matters enormously because we now have a vast and credible literature of research on the performance of children growing up in single-parent families, and they struggle mightily when compared to children within intact families on everything from staying in school to staying on a job.

In Fishtown, industriousness has declined, too. The percentage of males with a high-school education or less who describe themselves as not available for work has risen from 3 percent in the 1960s to 12 before the current recession got underway, when unemployment was still low. Similarly, the percentage of those working less than 40 hours a week has doubled over the decades to 20 percent of Fishtown adult workers.

Crime has soared in Fishtown. Even with the decline in American crime since the mid-1990s, the crime rate is still 4.7 times higher today in Fishtown than in 1960. The number of the neighborhood's adult residents in jail has increased from 215 per 100,000 in 1974 (the first year statistics are available) to 965 per 100,000 today.
For all the talk of how the evangelical religious revival is a lower-class phenomenon in America, Fishtown is actually far more secular than Belmont, too. Some 62 percent of Belmont's residents describe themselves as religious and attend church at least occasionally. By contrast, 59 percent of Fishtown's residents do not.

Murray has chosen to write specifically about white America as a way of getting beyond the complicating factors of racial or ethnic inequalities in the discussion of achievement in America. This is not, as Murray observes, a racial or ethnic issue when you see the way the behavior of a large chunk of the country's majority population has changed, too, in the last 50 years.

Murray quotes an early observer of America, Francis Grund, who observed in 1837 that the U.S Constitution was a simple document, yet it proved sufficient because of the unique qualities of those early Americans: ‘[The Constitution] can only suffice a people habitually correct in their actions," Grund wrote. "Change the domestic habits of the Americans," he added, and you would wind up with a different country in spite of our Constitution.

If Murray is right, we are getting to see now what that other country that Grund referred to will look like.

Steven Malanga is an editor for RealClearMarkets and a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute.


Add a comment


Urgent Petition

Sign the petition to stop Social Security Cuts and send a fax to every Member of Congress demanding they cut other spending, NOT SOCIAL SECURITY.
First Name

Last Name

Phone Number


Recent News

Reid Lets Obama, Holder Cover Up IRS Scandal

Sunday, March 23, 2014
An independent prosecutor — with no political agenda — is truly needed to uncover the origin and depth of the IRS's unconstitutional targeting scheme. By rejecting this request, the Justice Department puts politics ahead of the rule of law.
Read Full Story

A Special Prosecutor for the IRS

Wednesday, March 19, 2014
A special prosecutor, uncompromised by partisan political winds, is necessary to uncover what's going on at the IRS.
Read Full Story

President Obama's Growth Gap Hits $1.31 Trillion

Wednesday, March 5, 2014
Stagnation: With fourth-quarter GDP growth downgraded in the latest government report, President Obama's anemic economy stretches on. If this had been only an average recovery, we'd be $1.31 trillion richer.
Read Full Story

Michigan Township To Put Cameras ‘In Every Neighborhood’

Tuesday, March 4, 2014
“We are recording images that a police officer would see if he or she were standing in the same place”: Officials in Ypsilanti Township, Michigan are working with police to put surveillance cameras in every single neighborhood.
Read Full Story

SSI Candidate Questionnaire Responses

Monday, February 24, 2014
Candidates respond to the Questionaire SSI issued.
Read Full Story

Reasor Response To SSI Questionaire

Monday, February 24, 2014
Social Security Even though the latest Social Security Annual Trustees Reports states that Social Security can pay 100% of benefits until the year 2033, many members of Congress and policymakers still want to reduce the cost of the program now by various options.
Read Full Story

What ever happened to the Administrative Procedures Act?

Tuesday, February 11, 2014
For the second time in a year, the Obama administration is giving certain employers extra time before they must offer health insurance to almost all their full-time workers. Under new rules announced Monday by Treasury Department officials, employers with 50 to 99 workers will be given until 2016 — two years longer than originally envisioned under the Affordable Care Act — before they risk a federal penalty for not complying.
Read Full Story

SSI's Congressional Candidate Questionnaire

Tuesday, February 11, 2014
The Social Security Institute is sending out a questionaire to all Federal Candidates. Here is the content of the letter.
Read Full Story

Is GOP Sen. John Cornyn a Liberal?

Wednesday, January 15, 2014
“John Cornyn consistently doles out corporate welfare, supports the government snooping in our emails and phone calls, and supports cutting Social Security benefits for Republican grandparents and veterans across Texas,” said Green. “If that outrages Republican voters, they should by all means vote against him. And Steve Stockman should feel free to liberally use this quote in campaign materials.”
Read Full Story

Famous Republican faces primary challenge

Wednesday, January 15, 2014
Veteran Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, is seeking re-election as a “strong conservative” in a state known to dislike Washington and to be heavily dominated by the Republican Party. But observers say he is facing headwinds of his own making this election year.
Read Full Story
Read All Recent News

Get in the Know Now
Get SSI Email Alerts

Zip Code

Social Networks


Action Center